Security forces caused deliberate killing of protesters due to excessive force during the Mohamed Mahmoud clashes in 2011, according to human rights lawyer Mohsen Bahnasy.
In an exclusive interview with Egypt Independent, Bahnasy, a member of a fact-finding committee who investigated Mohamed Mahmoud Street, said security forces used excessively expired tear gas canisters and rubber bullets, firing them directly at sensitive areas of protesters bodies in order to cause grave injury. “[They fired] especially at faces from close range, causing deliberate killings from choking or piercing rubber bullets in sensitive parts,” he said.
Bahnasy says the report, which was commissioned during Morsy’s tenure and has yet to be released, found that both tear gas canisters and rubber bullets were used with the intention of killing rather than dispersing, given they were used in narrow, overcrowded and overpopulated areas.
Contrary to media reports, Bahnasy argues the Mohamed Mahmoud clashes began on 18 November 2011, spanning five consecutive days of intense fighting that left around 50 killed and 800 injured, including serious injuries and permanent disabilities as some protesters lost their eyes from rubber bullets.
For almost four or five days, the narrow Mohamed Mahmoud street witnessed a new suffocating tear gas canisters being shot to kill rather than to disperse. Amidst cloudy, choking clouds, motorcycles were constantly going back and forth carrying the wounded from frontlines to the makeshift emergency clinics. Shooting at eyes was a strangely frequent occurrence as many protesters including Ahmad Harrara, Malek Mostafa and others lost their eyes when snipers were targeting upper parts of bodies.
In March 2013, a Cairo court sentenced First Lieutenant Mahmoud El-Shinnawy — known as the “eye sniper” — to three years in prison for deliberately shooting at protesters’ eyes during the clashes.
Although the Ministry of Interior claims its security forces were merely defending the ministry headquarters, Bahnasy stresses the report showed no evidence that protesters attempted to actually attack the ministry.
On the evening of 20 November, the armed forces, to ease the escalating tensions between policemen and demonstrators, had officially notified the Interior Ministry to retreat back to the ministry headquarters and the armed forces will replace them but the ministry did not implement the order.
“When they were faced by the fact-finding committee members, the ministry offered the armed forces a letter to wash their hands of the killings,” said Bahnasy. “From this date, police and the armed forces became one united front against protesters.”
“Even some doctors were killed while they were rescuing the injured as Central Security kept opening intensive fire at Tahrir Square after forcing protesters to retreat from Mohamed Mahmoud Street,” Bahnasy said.
In Tahrir Square, Dr. Shady al-Nagar treated those wounded by gunfire and rubber bullets at a makeshift emergency care ward in the nearby mosque. “I have seen three people killed and many bone fractures. There is something wrong with these canisters. People are coming are chocked and close to death,” he said.
One ambulance pulled up in front of the mosque and a dozen men, limp and unconscious from teargas, spilled out into the arms of a crowd waiting to rush them to a street side triage station. “We are in a war,” Dr Nagar said. “This is not a protest.”
The ‘iron man’ behind Mohamed Mahmoud clashes
Bahnasy says the man behind the excessive force is no other than the decision-maker in the Interior Ministry, General Samy Seidhom.
As Bahnasy learned more about this figure, he became intrigued about the surrounding circumstances. Seidhom had a high positionin the Interior Ministry during the Mubarak regime and was close to Habib al-Adly, Mubarak’s interior minister. Despite the revolution that ousted Mubarak and the main figures in his regime, he kept not only his seat in power, but was also promoted until he became the ministry’s “iron man” after the revolution.
A 2011 report by Al-Wafd describes Seidhom, who was serving as the minister’s assistant for the security sector, as general of the “Tahrir battle,” in a reference to the Mohamed Mahmoud clashes, and the second most important person in the Interior Ministry after the minister himself as he was in charge of the violations that were committed by security forces during the clashes.
“General Seidhom was a spark of the Mohamed Mahmoud clashes as he was waging verbal attacks on revolutionaries, which escalated to opening fire on them,” the report reads.
Following the 30 June revolution, Seidhom was appointed to a position outside of the Interior Ministry, this time by a decree from interim President Adly Mansour on 13 August as al-Sharqya vice governor, in a surprise move to revolutionaries.
Interior Ministry console the Mohamed Mahmoud martyrs killed by its security forces
The Egyptian Interior Ministry has ironically issued on Sunday a statement to “commemorate” the second anniversary of Mohamed Mahmoud street clashes where the ministry’s soldiers were responsible for killing at least 50 and wounding more than 800 anti-SCAF protesters.
“Interior Ministry gives its condolences to all martyrs of the revolution who watered the tree of national struggle with their pure blood,” the statement reads, warning participants to be on “high alert for infiltrators” who seek to distort the meaning of the memorial.
The statement, the first of its kind from Interior Ministry, was met with an irony from both human rights lawyers and protesters, many of whom were injured in Mohamed Mahmoud clashes.
Bahnasy said the Interior Ministry still has not apologized for its involvement in killing Mohamed Mahmoud protesters. “Just offering condolences is a bare-faced cheek. If they were sincere, they would apologize and admit their responsibility for killing protesters,” he argued.
According to political activist Ahmad Doma, the memorial built at the epicenter of Tahrir square is “an attempt to appease the revolutionists with the goal of outbidding souls of martyrs.”
In the shadow of Mohamed Mahmoud street
Mohamad Mahmoud street, which connects Tahrir Square, where 25 January revolution was centered, to the headquarters of the Interior Ministry, whose brutality was the focal point of the revolution. The street has become a landmark of Egypt’s revolutionaries as it was a nucleus of the Third Square movement, which sides with neither the army nor the Muslim Brotherhood.
“Our conflict with Muslim Brotherhood does not mean favoring the military rule. Both failed to meet the demands of the revolution,” said Taha Abdul Moneim, a founding member of El-Fan Midan (Art is a Square), a monthly cultural event performing revolutionary art.
Despite winning the battle against police during the 25 January revolution, burning the National Democratic Party headquarters, storming police stations across the country and breaking into prisons, one thing protesters could not achieve was storming the Interior Ministry where snipers opened fire at anyone approaching from Tahrir Square through Mohamed Mahmoud street. Due to the rising number of killings approaching the Interior Ministry, protesters began warning others to return to Tahrir Square, as they were shooting live bullets.
Many people were killed promptly with live bullets during this day from the rooftop of the ministry, including Ahamad Basiony, an artist, experimental musician and teacher in his early thirties who was reported to have been shot in his chest while filming snipers who were shooting from the rooftop of the ministry.
On 19 November the same year, many things had changed in the political scene: Mubarak stepped down and the military junta was running the country for an undetermined transition period. The Supreme Council for the Armed Forces (SCAF) headed by Mubarak’s Defense Minister Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawy dealt with the same protesters who were part of the revolution brutally in almost 16 incidents during his tenure including incidents of the Cabinet, Abbassya, Manshyet Nasser, Israeli embassy and others.
‘Disgraceful’ position of Islamists towards Mohamed Mahmoud clashes
The Islamist block, who had earlier sweeping victory in the constitutional referendum outlining the country’s roadmap, thought they were doing well in elections and there was no reason to disrupt their success by joining or at least endorsing protesters in their fight against police.
For Mohamed Mahmoud Street, Muslim Brotherhood and the SCAF’s anti sentiment were peaked as Muslim Brotherhood led the Islamist trend to take the side of the military and Interior Ministry’s brutal take and they refused to participate in the protests that called for ousting Tantawy.
Muslim Brotherhood even went to the point of condemning protesters for clashing with security forces. In the Islamist-majority parliament, Islamist MPs defended policemen, describing protesters as feloul, or remnants of the old regime, as well as agents and saboteurs.
Doma told Al-Masry Al-Youm that the Supreme Council of Armed Forces, which were in power during the time of the Mohamed Mahmoud clashes are not the only ones responsible for the “massacre.” “All sides sold and conspired against the revolution, either physically, for [security forces]who committed the crime, or morally, for those who kept low-profile and supported the killer,” he added, referring to Muslim Brotherhood.
Ahmad Harara, who lost one eye by a bullet on January 28, 2011 in his struggle against Mubarak regime and lost the other by a sniper bullet during the Mohamed Mahmoud clashes, said in a TV interview commenting the anniversary that Muslim Brotherhood are a terrorist group that made a safe exit to the military junta who were in charge of violations. “The military regime tries to come back to power”, “I lost my eyes, but I did not lose my sight,” he said, slamming both the SCAF, Muslim Brotherhood and the figure behind the interim government, General Abdel Fattah el-Sisi.
The sticking point between the Islamic trend and revolutionary powers then was how they both see the roadmap to democracy. While both the SCAF and MB favored holding parliamentary elections before making the constitution as the right path, revolutionary powers believed the constitution should be first and above all should clean up the Interior Ministry, along with ending the military rule.
Sayyed Abdulatif from Imbaba, one of the poorest neighborhoods in northern Cairo, was one of people who participated in nationwide 30 June protests against Muslim Brotherhood-backed Morsy rule. His hostility against Muslim Brotherhood started when he was fighting against policemen at Mohamed Mahmoud clashes.
Abdulatif went to join protesters after his son Mohamed was “martyred” on 29 January in Tahrir Square. “Neither the SCAF nor Morsy exposed those in charge of killing my son and other martyrs,” he said, hoping that General Sisi would do what both Tantawy and Morsy failed to do which is to “claim the rights of the martyrs.”
We are aware of the importance of Personal Data (defined below) privacy, especially as we use such data to provide relevant services and information to our visitors. The EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the Swiss Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP) mandate high standards on how your Personal Data is collected, processed and stored, give you the right to access the Personal Data and request its erasure, and much more. In accordance with the legislation and recognizing the importance of this matter, we have prepared the below explanations on the protection of your Personal Data when visiting this website: https://marsad-egypt.info (the “Website”) and the rights you have as data subjects.
Please read these explanations carefully.
By browsing our Website, you agree to be bound by the terms of this policy. If you do not consent to these terms, we kindly ask you not to use our Website.
2. What is Personal Data?
Personal Data means any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person, i.e. an individual, regardless of the form in which it is expressed (hereafter, “Personal Data”). Personal data is information that identifies you as an individual, directly or indirectly, in particular by reference to identifiers such as a name, surname, location data, an online identifier, e-mail address, etc.
3. What Personal Data do we collect?
A. Personal Data you may provide us with
You may provide us with Personal Data, for instance by:
- filling out a contact form or
- subscribing to a newsletter.
We further collect the following Personal Data through cookies, analytics and other similar tools, such as:
(1) IP address of the requesting internet-enabled device,
(2) location of the requesting internet-enabled device based on the IP address,
(3) date and time of access,
(4) accessed resources on the Website,
(5) name and URL of the retrieved file,
(6) Website/application from which the access was made (referrer URL),
(7) browser you use,
(8) if necessary, the operating system of your internet-capable computer as well as the name of your access provider.
The cookies and scripts we use are the following:
This cookie is set by Addthis, a social sharing widget which is commonly embedded into our Website to enable visitors to share content with a range of networking and sharing platforms. This is a geolocation cookie to understand where the Website users are located.
1 year and 1 month
This cookie is set by Addthis, to store the user’s usage history
This cookie is set by Addthis, allowing users to share content across multiple social media websites
AddThis social sharing widget (Content sharing).
Third-party, Content sharing
AddThis social sharing widget
Third-party, Content sharing
This cookie is set by Addthis, to store a unique user ID
1 year and 1 month
The AddThis cookie is associated with the ‘share buttons’ where a user can email or share a link of a post to their friends.
The cookie is set by AddThis to store a unique user ID.
The cookie is set by AddThis to determine how often this social sharing service encounters the same user.
1 year and 1 month
Tracks user behavior on the websites that allow a user to share pages on social media using the AddThis tool. AddThis log the anonymous use to generate usage trends to improve the relevance of their services and advertising.
Third-party, Content sharing
Cookie set by doubleclick.net, in order to track the number of views of each page of the Website
Provided by Google Double Click, this cookie is used to identify a signed-in user
This cookie is set by Mailchimp in order to subscribe to the Website’s newsletter
End of Session to 1 year
AddThis cookie. Used to collect statistical data.
This cookie stores an updated page share count
1 year and 1 month
This cookie is set to make sure the user sees the updated count if they share a page and return to it before the share count cache is updated
This cookie is installed by Google Analytics to calculate visitor, session, campaign data and keep track of Website usage for the Website's analytics report. The cookies assign a randomly generated number to identify unique visitors
(Google Analytics) Contains campaign-related information. If you have linked your Google Analytics and Google Ads accounts, Google Ads website conversion tags will read this cookie unless you are opt-out.
This cookie is installed by Google Analytics. The cookie is used to store information of how visitors use the Website and helps in creating an analytics report of how the Website is doing
4. Why we collect such Personal Data?
(1) to authorize access to our Website,
(2) to make the functionalities of our Website available to you and to offer you additional functionalities,
(3) to improve the Website or our dedicated pages on social media,
(4) to store information about your preferences, allowing us to customize our Website according to your individual interests,
(5) to speed up your searches,
(6) to compile behavioral and statistical information about uses of our Website or our dedicated pages on social media, in particular to estimate our audience size and usage patterns,
(7) to produce aggregate insights that do not identify you,
(8) to identify you and log your use, recognize you when you return to our Website, track the activity on our Website and hold certain information.
The purpose for implementing all of the above is to maintain and monitor the performance of our Website and to constantly look to improve the site and the services it offers to our users. The legal basis we rely on to process your Personal Data is article 13(1) FADP and article 6(1)(f) of the GDPR, which allows us to process Personal Data when its necessary for the purposes of our legitimate interests.
In addition, cookies and other functionalities mentioned above which would go beyond the purposes of our legitimate interests (for example: Analytics Cookies), are implemented upon your acceptance through the means of our cookie banner.
5. Who is the Personal Data Controller ?
The controller of Personal Data on this Website is DCAF – Geneva Center for Security Sector Governance, Chemin Eugène-Rigot 2E, 1202, Geneva, Switzerland.
For any questions in relation to the way in which your Personal Data is stored and used, contact us at: firstname.lastname@example.org
6. Where do we store Personal Data and for how long ?
Your Personal Data is stored on servers located in Germany. If you are a subscriber of our mailing lists operated through Mailchimp, your Personal Data, which includes your name and email address, is stored on servers located in the United States.
We retain the Personal Data you provide to the extent necessary to provide you access to and use of our Website and its functionalities (like for instance our newsletters), as well as to the extent necessary to comply with our legal obligations (for example, if we are required to retain your data to comply with applicable laws), resolve disputes, and enforce our legal agreements and policies. The storage period of cookies depends on their purpose and is the same for everyone. We may retain de-personalized (anonymous) information after the deletion of your Personal Data.
7. Sharing, Selling and Transferring Personal Data
With third parties: The Personal Data collected are primarily intended for communicating with you and improving our services. However, we may give certain independent contractors and affiliates access to the Personal Data in order to assist us with the operation of our Website, as well as data management and marketing activities.
Cross-border data transfer: For some of the third-party service providers, we may transfer your data to one of their databases outside Switzerland or the European Economic Area, potentially including countries which may not have an adequate level of protection for your Personal Data. In such event, we enter into agreements with such third-parties ensuring an adequate level of protection for your Personal Data. By providing us with your Personal Data or by accepting analytic cookies, you agree that we may transfer, store and process your Personal Data outside of Switzerland and the European Economic Area – in particular in the USA – and acknowledge that governments in certain countries such as the USA have broad powers to access data for security, crime prevention and detection and law enforcement purposes.
Sharing with authorities: It is possible that we will need to disclose Personal Data when required by law or if we have a good faith belief that disclosure is necessary to investigate, prevent, or take action regarding suspected or actual illegal activities or to assist government enforcement agencies, investigate and defend ourselves against any third-party claims or allegations, protect the security or integrity of our Website or our dedicated pages on social media, or exercise or protect the rights and safety of our users, personnel, or others.
We attempt to notify users about legal demands for their Personal Data when appropriate in our judgment and technically feasible, unless prohibited by law or court order or when the request is an emergency. We may dispute such demands when we believe, in our discretion, that the requests are overbroad, vague or lack proper authority, but we do not promise to challenge every demand.
8. Withdrawal of consent for processing of Personal Data
At any time, you have the right to withdraw your consent for the processing of Personal Data for a particular purpose or for all purposes with which you have consented.
For the withdrawal of your consent, please send a written request to DCAF – Geneva Center for Security Sector Governance, Chemin Eugène-Rigot 2E, 1202 Geneva, Switzerland, or by e-mail to: email@example.com.
In case of withdrawal of your consent, we will delete all collected Personal Data or exclude them from automatic processing in accordance with the specificities of your request.
Please be aware that the withdrawal of your consent will not impact the lawfulness of processing based on your consent before it was withdrawn and the use of Personal Data as needed to comply with our legal obligations.
9. Your rights in the field of Personal Data
Right to update, correct and erasure: At any time, you have the right to obtain from us the correction of inaccurate or incomplete Personal Data. At any time, you also have the right to obtain from us access to the Personal Data that we have collected and the right to obtain immediate erasure of your Personal Data.
Right to restriction of processing: You have the right to request that we restrict the processing of your Personal Data.
Right to data portability: You have the right to be provided with a copy of the Personal Data we have on you in a structured, machine-readable and commonly used format.
Right to object: You have the right to object to our processing of your Personal Data.
Right of access: At any time, you have the right to obtain from us confirmation as to whether your Personal Data are being processed and, where that is the case, access to the Personal Data.
Personal data breach: In the case of a Personal Data breach, we will without undue delay and, where feasible, not later than 72 hours after having become aware of it, notify the Personal Data breach to the competent supervisory authority.
Right to complain to an authority: You have the right to complain to a data protection authority about our collection and use of your Personal Data. For more information, please contact your local data protection authority in the European Economic Area (EEA) or in Switzerland.
10. Security of your Personal Data
The security of your Personal Data is important to us, but no method of transmission over the Internet, or method of electronic storage is 100% secure. While we strive to use technical and organizational commercially acceptable means to protect your Personal Data against manipulation, partial or complete loss and unauthorized access by third party, we cannot guarantee its absolute security.